

Is damaged Detective Pikachu promo card eligible for PSA 1 grade?
So I’m just about finished with my Detective Pikachu master set. It’s not a huge set by any means, but this one means more to me than most of the bigger sets I’ve worked on. Detective Pikachu is honestly Top 3 movies I can watch over and over again without getting tired of it. I swear I’ve watched this DVD a thousand times at this point. I actually have a pristine copy of the Detective Pikachu promo still sitting inside the DVD case exactly how it came. That one is getting a special mission. I’m planning to send it to Ryan Reynolds’ talent agency and see if I can get him to sign it. If that works out, that card will instantly become one of the coolest pieces in my collection. But then I had another idea… What if I paired it with the exact opposite condition card — a PSA 1 slab of the same promo? Just not signed. I found this one on eBay and honestly… it might be perfect for it. The thing has been through war. Creases across the entire card, surface damage, edge wear — it’s got the full battle story. And that’s where I’m curious what everyone here thinks. Do you think this is PSA 1 material? Or do you think it’s actually too far gone to even get a grade and would come back as “Authentic / No Grade” instead? Part of me really hopes it lands the PSA 1, because the idea of displaying: • A signed pristine promo • Next to a PSA 1 survivor copy …just seems like a fun and unique way to finish off the Detective Pikachu set. What do you all think — PSA 1 contender or PSA reject? 😆
Other listings for Pikachu Illustrator PSA 10
View all →
